Barnes & Noble Nook Gets Trashed By Archos 5 Internet Tablet

Liza Daly is prominent in the eBook community as someone who knows the IDPF ePub spec inside and out.

She bought a Nook for testing purposes, afflicting it with ePub eBooks that are totally-compliant to the spec and which anyone is bound to encounter at some point.

The results were not good at all.

She details what happened in her post: Nook as an ePub renderer: review.

One part of this post concerns me, as I'm cited:

Here’s where things really fell down for me. I tried an edition of The People of the Abyss by Jack London. Mike Cane used this book to demonstrate some problems with ADE’s rendering.

This is a complex ebook though by no means an extreme outlier. It is hand-coded, which means that it doesn’t have unnecessary auto-generated markup, and it’s valid.

Now pay attention here:

In most books I tested, the re-formatting between chapters or font changes took between 4-5 seconds. That’s slightly longer than the Kindle 1 or Sony PRS-505, which are the two devices I have for comparison.

For this particular book, re-formatting a chapter or going to a new chapter took 30 seconds.

Boldfaced emphasis is in the original!

Frankly, I was shocked to read this. It’s the first time I’ve heard of any device performing this poorly on any ePub.

It also got under my skin and I asked someone to run that ePub of The People of the Abyss on his Archos 5 Internet Tablet with the Aldiko eBook reading software.

Here is a video of him doing just that:

It has no problems whatsoever!

I can quibble about the photos being cut off from page to page — but that’s something I think Aldiko can fix. What’s most important here is that the Nook really, really wasn’t in any shape to ship to customers.

It also drives home my point that eInk devices are low-end disppointing creatures bound for swift obsolescence next year as a flood of Android-powered mini-tablets enter stores. At some point, one of these will have the ability to do Adobe DRMed ePub eBooks — and then it’s all over for the eInk Squad.

And let’s not forget the entry of the Apple iTablet, either!

If you’d like to try that specific ePub of The People of the Abyss, it’s the first download in the list on this page.

If you own the new Camangi WebStation, try it on that and leave a Comment!

But hey — just don’t download it to try out. Read it too. It’s a great book and reflects our time right now.

Previously here:

Camangi WebStation Pre-Orders Are Go
Android OS/Archos 5 Internet Tablet Notes For Saturday November 28, 2009
Android OS/Archos 5 Internet Tablet Notes For Friday November 27, 2009
Syntron Android Mini-Tablet: 3G, 8.9″ Screen
Camangi Android Mini-Tablet: ePub Built-In
Android OS/Archos 5 Internet Tablet Notes For Monday November 2, 2009
The Coming Android Mini-Tablet Flood
Is Adobe Hindering eBooks?
Archos 5 Internet Tablet Notes For Sunday October 25, 2009
Dell Tops The Archos 5 Internet Tablet
Android OS Aldiko ePub Display Challenge
eBook Use On The Archos 5 Internet Tablet
eBook Notes For Monday, October 5, 2009

5 Responses to Barnes & Noble Nook Gets Trashed By Archos 5 Internet Tablet

  1. Man, what a mess those dedicated ebook devices are.
    Which has now got me convinced (not that I needed more convincing anyway) to wait for… you know… something better to come along (can you say Apple tablet?)

  2. MikeMc says:

    B&N definitely rushed the nook to market, from what I’ve read thus far the nook firmware is not ready for prime time. Of course the “release it now patch it later” mindset has been endemic in the tech industry for years (see Archos 5). On a slightly different note perhaps it’s time to change the name of this blog from “The eBook Test” to “The Apple Tablet Hype Page”.

    • mikecane says:

      >>>On a slightly different note perhaps it’s time to change the name of this blog from “The eBook Test” to “The Apple Tablet Hype Page”.

      And when the iTablet is out there, then what?

      You conveniently ignore the fact there are plenty of non-Apple posts here. Android interests me greatly too, for one.

      • Thomas says:

        What seems to interest you is how Android fails to Apple software. You repeat the feud (and often prove bias) between Apple and Google. (You are clearly biased for Apple.)

        • mikecane says:

          This Comment was let through so you can see this reply: You are banned from this blog based on your Comment maligning the writers in my masthead. Go away, you lowlife scum.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: